Skip to content

Comment on Trellis – 3D mesh generative model

Comments

Looks like the generated wireframes are still terrible and would need to be redone by hand. So no need for artists to worry about their job security just yet.

Question: How much do crappy wireframes actually matter?

From a performance pov I've imported ridiculous meshes not intended for games into unreal. It worked.

I can see this being ok for anything other than triple A games right?

Three things:

1. Unless we're strictly talking about static meshes (such as for scenery), building out the rigging/animation for garbage topologies is going to be absolute hell.

2. Your performance POV was for ONE mesh, but if your quad/triangle count is 10x higher than it needs to be, how well is it going to scale particularly on low-end gaming platforms?

3. Lighting/shadows/reflections can produce some pretty UGLY effects when your surface polygons are a mess.

They matter as much as good quality code matters. Even more so actually.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.