Skip to content

Comment on The Crisis in String Theory Is Worse Than You Thinkparent

Comments

The question, I think, is “how many alternative theories were dismissed by no funding?” IF there was other people asking for funding for other topics or theories were dismissed because “strings are cool” then I expect some explanation. And boy there were other theories and projects asking for funding!

Do not read "the system is perfect" or even "good" from my post. I'm focusing only on the claim from the post above that there is "zero accountability". The people accountable are everyone in the chain I described and the whole thing hinges on people that ultimately answer to elections.

how many alternative theories were dismissed by no funding

it's an interesting question - you should be able to request this information from the funding bodies!

Do you think you can't? It's all covered under FOIA. Bureaucratic stuff like this is in fact FOIA's wheelhouse.

No I was suggesting that he should ask for it, instead of assuming there weren't good reasons for the choices that were made.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.