Skip to content

Comment on Musicmap: The genealogy and history of popular music genres

Comments

Missing Jazz manouche, aka Gypsy Jazz.

Django had immense influence in most 20th century guitar players, directly and indirectly. Many of the biggest Jazz guitarists had tracks or even albums dedicated to him.

"World|Other" is doing a lot of heavy lifting . . . "AfroBeat" is a handwave for a continent larger and more populated than the US, Africa by decades deserves its own map of styles.

As always, I feel like visualizations/"maps" like these always tell us more about the author's biases than it does explaining whatever musical categorization they wanted to explain.

At least Ishkur had fun with their descriptions :)

There are biases all over, hard to avoid; but even Fanshawe's problematic African Sanctus had more breadth and depth of Africa than this chart - and where's the Australian indigenous space-age lounge trip-hop FFS .. ;)

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.