Why would an app be a requirement for a search engine? To me it would make more sense to be aligned with how many users the search engine has. 5,000 unique per month, or whatever.
I have the Kagi app on my iPhone, but just so it can be an extension in Safari. In a perfect world, I would be able to go into the settings, add a custom search engine, and be done with it. No app or extension needed. Then when it hits a threshold it can be added as an easy option for people to pick from a list.
Why would an app be a requirement for a search engine?
Because otherwise you can’t use it as a default search engine on the platform, because it doesn’t allow it. Same for iOS. They had to write an app to intercept search requests and redirect to Kagi.
You can totally use it as the default search engine, all you have to do is switch to a different launcher that actually gives you the freedom to customize your search settings bases on your preferences. Eg, Nova Launcher, Lawnchair, Niagara, etc.
Well, launcher is a very central part of your phone experience. I don’t think many people will change that just because they can.
Personally, this is one of the reasons I don’t like android anymore. You have to tweak it endlessly to make it halfway work. The platform’s management load is too much. I don’t want to manage and mangle another computer in my pocket. It wastes too much time.
I suppose. Since there was a threshold to cross, I was assuming the search would need to get baked in as an option natively.
I tend to like how Firefox does it, where any search the user goes to, there is an option to add it as a search option and set it as the default. This should be the standard all browsers use. Junking up a phone with apps just for what is ultimately a setting change isn’t ideal.
The hacks Kagi has to do for Safari is annoying. They’ve gone so far as to make their own browser to make it better, though I’m sure that’s not their only reason. I’ve had some issues with the Safari extension over the years. I hope Apple changes their approach on this.
Comments
Why would an app be a requirement for a search engine? To me it would make more sense to be aligned with how many users the search engine has. 5,000 unique per month, or whatever.
I have the Kagi app on my iPhone, but just so it can be an extension in Safari. In a perfect world, I would be able to go into the settings, add a custom search engine, and be done with it. No app or extension needed. Then when it hits a threshold it can be added as an easy option for people to pick from a list.
Because otherwise you can’t use it as a default search engine on the platform, because it doesn’t allow it. Same for iOS. They had to write an app to intercept search requests and redirect to Kagi.
You can totally use it as the default search engine, all you have to do is switch to a different launcher that actually gives you the freedom to customize your search settings bases on your preferences. Eg, Nova Launcher, Lawnchair, Niagara, etc.
Well, launcher is a very central part of your phone experience. I don’t think many people will change that just because they can.
Personally, this is one of the reasons I don’t like android anymore. You have to tweak it endlessly to make it halfway work. The platform’s management load is too much. I don’t want to manage and mangle another computer in my pocket. It wastes too much time.
I suppose. Since there was a threshold to cross, I was assuming the search would need to get baked in as an option natively.
I tend to like how Firefox does it, where any search the user goes to, there is an option to add it as a search option and set it as the default. This should be the standard all browsers use. Junking up a phone with apps just for what is ultimately a setting change isn’t ideal.
The hacks Kagi has to do for Safari is annoying. They’ve gone so far as to make their own browser to make it better, though I’m sure that’s not their only reason. I’ve had some issues with the Safari extension over the years. I hope Apple changes their approach on this.