Skip to content

Comment on Python in Excel – Available Nowparent

Comments

from what I understand from seeing youtube videos of it in action, you can use python functions libraries for the calculation part, but one of the strenghts of VBA was that you could interact with the Excel software itself, and that bit hasn't been replicated in python.

people liked they could set up scripts in VBA for automating routine tasks, but hated the VBA language syntax, from what I've understood, and wished they could program those functions in some more popular language like Python etc. But that isn't what this is.

It's exactly why I built xlwings, to replace VBA with Python. Python in Excel instead is a competitor to the Excel formula language.

Tools like xlwing are excellent, but people want to start excel first and stay in that interface.

If we are going to open up Jupyter notebooks, we have already failed.

(That's why VBA works, it's the only thing that runs on locked down corp laptops, because it's inside Excel.)

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.