Skip to content

Comment on US FDA approves nasal spray alternative to EpiPen for allergic reactionsparent

Comments

Slam dunk against EpiPen’s de facto monopoly.

EpiPens have been generic for many years and most people don't buy the brand name EpiPen unless their insurance makes it free. Check CVS and goodrx

The ground truth I have from people in my circle is that it is still expensive and challenging to get them. Maybe that is not broadly the case, but based on that ground truth, I want cheap alternatives at scale.

Sure, making things cheaper is always better. I'm just responding to the word "monopoly" which seems to get tossed around whenever anything is expensive without any thought on why it's expensive.

The actual price of 2pk epipen is $109.99 and it lasts many years. As I mentioned in another comment, "Forty EpiPen and EpiPen Jr auto-injectors that had been expired for 1 to 50 months were tested. All 40 auto-injectors contained more than 80 percent of the labeled dose" https://www.foodallergy.org/fare-blog/expired-epinephrine-ca...

Unless some institution forces you to pay more (Eg schools and allergy shot providers checking expiry dates) the actual cost is ~$25/year if you don't have decent insurance and ~$0 if you do

Sure, making things cheaper is always better. I'm just responding to the word "monopoly" which seems to get tossed around whenever anything is expensive without any thought on why it's expensive.

Paying hundreds of millions of dollars to settle antitrust claims sounds like a monopoly to me.

https://www.biopharmadive.com/news/how-mylan-ended-up-with-a...

https://kffhealthnews.org/news/behind-the-epipen-monopoly-lo...

https://www.courthousenews.com/10th-circuit-asked-to-revive-...

https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/pfizer-pay-50-mln-s...

https://www.nbcnews.com/business/business-news/epipen-maker-...

Why are you linking 2016 articles in 2024? Back then the generic wasn't widely available

Because options prevent further monopoly activity that was proven to have happened (citations provided). You seem to have some interest in avoiding the truth and facts around this topic, which is odd. First “there was no monopoly,” and then “well, it was a while ago so it doesn’t matter now.” It happened, and it could happen again. Also, it isn’t enough to be generic based on manufacturing complexity and capacity, which can create a monopoly situation for a generic.

First “there was no monopoly,”

Nope, first "there is no monopoly". I don't give a shit about 2016

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.