Skip to content

Comment on There's more to mathematics than rigour and proofs (2007)parent

Comments

That's totally a tangent but I was reading a bit and it happens that, in practice, real cables bend in an inbetween curve between catenaries and parabolas

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catenary#Catenary_bridges

Comparison of a catenary arch (black dotted curve) and a parabolic arch (red solid curve) with the same span and sag. The catenary represents the profile of a simple suspension bridge, or the cable of a suspended-deck suspension bridge on which its deck and hangers have negligible weight compared to its cable. The parabola represents the profile of the cable of a suspended-deck suspension bridge on which its cable and hangers have negligible weight compared to its deck. The profile of the cable of a real suspension bridge with the same span and sag lies between the two curves. The catenary and parabola equations are respectively, y = cosh x and y = x²( (cosh 1) − 1) + 1

https://www.quora.com/How-do-you-tell-the-difference-between...

If the chain is carrying nothing other than its own weight, the resulting shape is a "catenary". If the chain is like a suspended cable carrying a deck below it, and its own weight is nothing compared to that of the deck, the resulting shape is a "parabola".

Which shows that sometimes your model (either using pure math or a simulation) is too simple to capture whatever is going on in the real world. (it gets further complicated when one considers elasticity etc)

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.