Skip to content

Comment on Ask HN: What makes Windows 11 perform much worse than Windows XP?parent

Comments

P.S. I want to add ancillary rant here about the MODERN concept of PROFESSIONAL EDITION: I also have Apple computers, a MacBook Pro for example. If I take a MacOS version from the past, let say Snow Leopard, and compare it at the one in use on that computer right now , an allegedly PRO system, do the new version improve my job ? Because this means "PRO", right? Something you use in your profession , right? REALLY, NO, let's add some details: - Snow Leopard gave me the feel of something FAST , this one only at the beginning, after some service upgrades of the OS in use, the infamous rainbow disk started to spawn;

- On Snow leopard I could use dtrace/dtruss , here if I have to investigate an application, I have to reboot the system, disable the SIP and wait that the problem manifest. This is especially stupid, I mean to force a professional to follow this workflow depriving him root privilege on it's own system. Image if Linux decide to do something like that and you have to reboot a server to use trace.

- X is still a thing, I use it at work, In Snow Leopard it was integrated , now I have to install XQuartz, that, for what I know is a one-man-project, with all the problem it implies ( and I want to thank the maintainer for the recent bug fixes , solving problem I had ); - CUDA: I can't use CUDA, an industry standard on MAC, I was able to use it on previous version of MacOs until Apple decided it's bad for us, publicizing the delusional idea that I can do the same jobs of an high end GPU on an Mxxx processor.

- ZSH: at some point, Apple also decided BASH is bad for you and your life will be better with ZSH. So, let's throw away a consolidated standard tool for some hipster stuff facilitating script kiddies to have multicoloured, fluorescent, pimped cursors on it ! Obviously not 100% compatible with BASH, so you should modify your scripts to conform. Luckily, Bash can be restored.

So I can do LESS with this MODERN OS that a 10 years older version. But now it has more vivid colours and that's good for your mood. And, again, my perception is that it's slower, doing the same tasks I did on Snow Leopard.

Are pro version adding some professional tool, capability, whatever that improve my professional experience or productivity ? NO.

So, how is justified the "professional" adjective here ? It seems more marketing gimmick to me. I feel less productive, but I have Apple TV, Siri and tons of bloatware should be present on a PRO machine and sometimes, A VENT. Yes, the difference from pro and non-pro sometimes is that the pro version can better dissipate heat.

Think about it.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.