Skip to content

Comment on Hybrid-Net: Real-time audio source separation, generate lyrics, chords, beat

Comments

Tried it on a couple of my wife’s songs and she said it was quite inaccurate in terms of chords and tabs (the lyrics were pretty close though). This seems like one of those use cases where it’s not particularly useful until it gets above some minimum accuracy threshold.

Thanks for sharing your experience. We appreciate the feedback. It's clear that improving accuracy, especially with chords and tabs, is a priority for us. We're committed to enhancing the accuracy of our tool to meet your expectations and provide a more valuable experience.

At this point, I'm conflicted. The lyrics testing went well for me, but I'm not proficient in chords. Are the chord results really that poor? I wonder if I can use it to play my favorite songs in real life.

I play guitar/piano, and I concur that they’re not great. I tried “Vagabond (acoustic)” by Wolfmother. I figured it would have an easier time because it’s just a vocal and an acoustic guitar. Some of the notes in the tabs are right, but the melody is too simplistic. All of the embellishments are also missing. It’s interesting how the mile-high view isn’t so bad though. If I sat down to figure out the notes for a track no tabs exist for, this might look like a rough approximation of what I’d start with.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.