Skip to content

Comment on Police, Prosecutors Used Junk Science to Decide 911 Callers Were Liars (2022)parent

Comments

judges, attorneys, police and prosecutors all work on the same team

These guys ultimately are desperately wanting a black box computer algorithm, where 1. you type in the suspect's name, 2. the algorithm spits out "guilty" and 3. that is admissible to a jury. If they had this, every single one of their jobs are a piece of cake:

A crime happens. The police can now pick up literally anyone they don't like. The prosecuting attorney doesn't have to do anything--just enter the suspect into the algorithm. The judge doesn't have to do anything. Computer Says YES. The jury doesn't have to do anything. Computer Says YES so I can convict and go home. This is the future of law enforcement. They just have to get that darn black box approved and invulnerable to defense attorneys.

Police always want their jobs to be easier. Everybody wants their own job to be easier.

The problem is that in a free society policing needs to be hard. Places where policing is easy are called police states.

Yes, it's telling how excited I've if the prosecutors in the story was because they got a conviction. Not excited by whether justice was done.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.