People act like this is the end of the world for regulation but it isn't. Nor is getting rid of chevron deference a bad thing. SCOTUS' intent here is pretty clear. If congress wants to delegate a power to the executive then they must explicitly do so. And courts shouldn't take regulators at their word in cases anymore but actually test to see if what they claim makes sense or is in good faith, you know, like everyone else must do in court.
The actual issue relevant to this article is that America lacks any real overarching privacy law. We need one badly. Congress is unlikely to come up with one on its own. So people need to get active and lobby for one. We've made good progress with right to repair in the last few years so that shows doomerism is just that. Get off your ass and spread the word. Normies have been deaf to us saying this is problem for years. Maybe when you tell them that their insurance will go up every time they have spirited drive they will actually pay attention.
Sometimes the way that good things get done is bad, and we'd be better served by fixing the bad way than continuing to reinforce the duct tape over a broken underlying process.
Yes, that means things seem to go backwards in the short term, but creating better underlying processes (e.g. Congress being forced by voters to do its job, passing a federal US privacy law) removes impediments to really proceeding forward.
Comments
People act like this is the end of the world for regulation but it isn't. Nor is getting rid of chevron deference a bad thing. SCOTUS' intent here is pretty clear. If congress wants to delegate a power to the executive then they must explicitly do so. And courts shouldn't take regulators at their word in cases anymore but actually test to see if what they claim makes sense or is in good faith, you know, like everyone else must do in court.
The actual issue relevant to this article is that America lacks any real overarching privacy law. We need one badly. Congress is unlikely to come up with one on its own. So people need to get active and lobby for one. We've made good progress with right to repair in the last few years so that shows doomerism is just that. Get off your ass and spread the word. Normies have been deaf to us saying this is problem for years. Maybe when you tell them that their insurance will go up every time they have spirited drive they will actually pay attention.
Hear hear.
Sometimes the way that good things get done is bad, and we'd be better served by fixing the bad way than continuing to reinforce the duct tape over a broken underlying process.
Yes, that means things seem to go backwards in the short term, but creating better underlying processes (e.g. Congress being forced by voters to do its job, passing a federal US privacy law) removes impediments to really proceeding forward.