Skip to content

Comment on Mistral Remove "Committing to open models" from their websiteparent

Comments

I actually see copyright and patents as a tiny socialist of the present composite system, i.e. 'to each according to his contribution'.

They're one of the small ways in which someone who actually does something gets a temporary monopoly on his little contribution, and it's something which is necessary to make the whole edifice function, because there is a need to ensure that people actually invent things and start companies, and if it were up to capital owners only, that wouldn't really happen. Ordinary people would have a very minimal incentive to use their intellect to discover genuinely novel things.

Public schooling is another, which is rather a socialist component, a communist component, a 'to each according to his need'.

But I suppose my view is consistent with a view that capitalism doesn't play nice with digital assets as well, but the present system does need these stabilising socialist and communist elements in order function and I think these socialist and communist components are genuine parts of the present system, just as capital ownership and wage labour are.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.