Skip to content

Comment on Chip Defense

Comments

Cute idea. I like that you can click on the creeps to invert their value.

However, I found that the path logic inscrutable and frustrating. The creeps take a random path when they reach some intersections (I think? There was no explanation and no obvious pattern). Success in stage 8 seems to depend entirely on luck. I would expect a game themed around computer logic to be more deterministic.

I had the same issue, and multiple levels have the same flaw to some extent. I also had a few levels where I couldn't figure out a reliable strategy without selling and rebuying MEM chips. Still had a lot of fun, though.

Found the dev talking about the pathing: https://github.com/ochadenas/cpudefense/issues/46#issuecomme...

You can't tell from sight which way the attackers will take. It works this way:
- For each level, there are pre-defined tracks.
- Each attacker randomly chooses one of these tracks.
- In other words, the path of an attacker is determined in the moment it starts on the board. For level 8 in particular, 2 out of 5 attackers will take the upper loop, 2 out of 5 the lower loop, and 1 out of 5 will go straight to the CPU.
- The game has no notion of "left" or "right".
Similar for the attackers strengths: For each wave, a maximum value is set. Each attacker randomly gets a number ranging from 0 to this maximum, but you can't tell which one. If you are lucky, there are lots of 0's.
AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.