Skip to content

Comment on Anon Boeing engineer reveals why the 737 door blew offparent

Comments

Competent designers do think about those things.

Competent designers and engineers consider the risks of incorrect assembly, and depending on risk assessment (probability vs severity of failure), and cost-benefit assessment (cost of redesign vs cost of inspection), and based on that decide on if further mitigations are required.

Generally if it's possible that a complete failure of process happens, designers will plan for that. Anything outside of fully automated assembly processes with interlocks and safety checks warrant that to a decent designer. You cite cost of redesign but we're talking design in the first place. What's on the table in this discussion is design, not response to failures.

Sure that makes sense.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.