Skip to content

Comment on Ask HN: Why aren't all heaters computers?

Comments

Computers aren't free, if it costs even $1 to add a computer that generates enough heat (several hundred watts) to be useful as a heater...why not just omit the computer and make an extra dollar of profit, or charge less and undercut competitors that have computers?

Also consider the externalities...making unnecessary computers contributes to e-waste, it increases demand for rare-earth metals that are often mined in extraordinarily bad conditions (slavery and child labor)...

All this for what benefit? Is there a market of people that want to use a computer attached to a space heater? What useful thing is this computer going to do? Maybe it makes sense as a wi-fi repeater or something, but once again as the manufacturer what's easier/cheaper/simpler to design - a computer that generates heat and does some useful software task, or a fat 1500 Watt resistor that converts DC current directly into heat?

All that said, you might be on to something. With some clever advertising and marketing promotionals, I bet you can convert some portion of the space heater market into "premium" users of this contraption, all while make them feel eco-friendly through a greenwashing campaign.

So my answer is, this product doesn't exist for lack of technical creativity - it exists because the advertising industry hasn't sunk to such depths as to market this product yet.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.