Skip to content

Comment on eBPF Verification Is Untenableparent

Comments

1. Using eBPF requires root

2. The verifier checks memory bounds access, guarantees termination in a certain number of instructions, and restricts function calls to a limited number of helper functions provided by the kernel.

3. BPF code runs on a vm, think like the jvm. It’s impossible to express a lot of nasty stuff given the restrictive bytecode language.

There have been bugs in the verifier, but overall it works very well, the biggest issue being that it drastically limits the complexity of your program.

1. Using eBPF requires root

Unprivileged eBPF has been around for a long time.

Except that it's been almost universally disabled, for many years. Nobody trusts it.

Idk if I'd call 2 years "many", but yes.

In eBPF years, 2 years is an eternity.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.