Skip to content

Comment on Ask HN: How to Protect Ideas and Implementation?

Comments

A few comments:

1. If your idea is truly novel, i.e., you have invented something new, then you can patent it. But the question then becomes which geographies. For e.g., if you patent your work in Country X, then it is not protected in other countries. You will have to file in each country's patent office separately. If your idea is truly novel, then consider the costs of global filing of patents and evaluate against the benefits.

2. Software and algorithms are not patentable in many jurisdictions. e.g., India. Since you mention UI and backend implementation, it is very likely that it won't be patentable in many jursdictions that prohibit sofware/algorithm patents. For a more detailed analysis on software patentability conditions see: [1]

3. For sofware, you can take reasonable precautions against blatant copying by

- partitioning your software into server-side implementation that runs in hosts that you control and manage entirely

- client side software that requires run-time license keys (to control and keep track of usage, trial versions etc.,)

- focusing on security in your system from day 1 (includes source code security, release management, encryption, key management/distribution etc., some aspects of this fashionably called CI/CD or DevOps)

Having said all this, ideas are truly worthless. Iterating your product with paying customers is the hallmark of good execution. Execution is gold.

And remember: Most people will be thinking that they can implement it better than you and are unlikely to copy your stuff.

The hard part is acquiring customers, meeting their needs, addressing problems and retaining them by providing excellent service.

[1]: https://www.mondaq.com/india/trade-secrets/810286/is-softwar...

Thank you for the detailed response.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.