No matter the challenges, Facebook still has one thing going for it that will keep it solid for years to come: switching costs. Rebuilding a social network, from the ground up, is hard and annoying work (sorry, G+, but it's true).
Back in the day, switching from Yahoo to Google was as simple as entering a new URL into one's browser. Switching from AOL to a different ISP was slightly more difficult, but not much more difficult than cancelling one subscription and signing up for another.
But if you look at the landscape of interest-based or activity-based social networking utilities today -- Pinterest, Tumblr, and so forth -- they really don't look like Facebook killers. In fact, many of them have integrated Facebook credentialing. In aggregate, they may take user eyeballs off of the Facebook homepage -- but they aren't taking user accounts away from Facebook.
Facebook seems to realize that the key to its longevity will be as a de facto social and identity credential, and not necessarily as a destination website (although that's nice, too). People may not want to spend as much time on Facebook.com as they once did, but it will take a lot to get them to abandon the Facebook ecosystem altogether.
Accordingly, I submit that the real challenge Facebook faces isn't monetizing display ad space on Facebook.com; it's monetizing the rest of the internet as credentialed by Facebook. (To your point, the "off-Facebook" ad platform). This challenge isn't insurmountable, either. In fact, it doesn't strain the imagination to think of an AdSense-competitor product that could serve up contextually relevant advertising to FB-credentialed users as they surfed the rest of the web.
Comments
No matter the challenges, Facebook still has one thing going for it that will keep it solid for years to come: switching costs. Rebuilding a social network, from the ground up, is hard and annoying work (sorry, G+, but it's true).
Back in the day, switching from Yahoo to Google was as simple as entering a new URL into one's browser. Switching from AOL to a different ISP was slightly more difficult, but not much more difficult than cancelling one subscription and signing up for another.
But if you look at the landscape of interest-based or activity-based social networking utilities today -- Pinterest, Tumblr, and so forth -- they really don't look like Facebook killers. In fact, many of them have integrated Facebook credentialing. In aggregate, they may take user eyeballs off of the Facebook homepage -- but they aren't taking user accounts away from Facebook.
Facebook seems to realize that the key to its longevity will be as a de facto social and identity credential, and not necessarily as a destination website (although that's nice, too). People may not want to spend as much time on Facebook.com as they once did, but it will take a lot to get them to abandon the Facebook ecosystem altogether.
Accordingly, I submit that the real challenge Facebook faces isn't monetizing display ad space on Facebook.com; it's monetizing the rest of the internet as credentialed by Facebook. (To your point, the "off-Facebook" ad platform). This challenge isn't insurmountable, either. In fact, it doesn't strain the imagination to think of an AdSense-competitor product that could serve up contextually relevant advertising to FB-credentialed users as they surfed the rest of the web.