Skip to content

Comment on “Pigeon Neck” Illusion (2014)parent

Comments

It took me several minutes before I could see the illusion. I just saw grey rectangles and pigeons smoothly moving to the right and had no idea what the “illusion” was supposed to be.

Now I wonder how much it depends on the gamma. I understand there's some differences depending on the hardware, browser and image format/metadata. By default we may all see a different shade of grey, affecting how much of an illusion we get.

Edit: checked Firefox and Chrome on Android and they look exactly the same (work on me). Low brightness works better than full brightness.

That’s certainly a possible factor. I’m on an iPhone 14 Pro with brightness at medium levels in an averagely lit room using Safari. I just tried on my Mac’s XDR display and it’s similar: I can either see or not see the illusion (now that I know what the illusion looks like I can turn it on/off in my head).

It took me several minutes before I could see the illusion. I just saw grey rectangles and pigeons smoothly moving to the right and had no idea what the “illusion” was supposed to be.

Same here. After a bit I could see some worm stretching if I focused on particular points in the image.

I noticed that as soon as I registered all of the movement, my eyes fixed a certain way that they do when I'm driving and navigating an overly complex traffic situation. I was super reluctant to try to focus them any other way.

When I started messing with the color I ran into that. If I shifted to a different grey, it just looked smooth to me. But either extreme, black or white, and the illusion was there.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.