Skip to content

Comment on The Uninhabitable Earth (2017)

Comments

I am 55 years old now. I remember all the doomsday prophets of the 70's (and after).

     1. 1967: Dire Famine Forecast By 1975
     2. 1969: Everyone Will Disappear In a Cloud Of Blue Steam By 1989 (1969)
     3. 1970: Ice Age By 2000
     4. 1970: America Subject to Water Rationing By 1974 and Food Rationing By 1980
     5. 1971: New Ice Age Coming By 2020 or 2030
     6. 1972: New Ice Age By 2070
     7. 1974: Space Satellites Show New Ice Age Coming Fast
     8. 1974: Another Ice Age?
     9. 1974: Ozone Depletion a ‘Great Peril to Life (data and graph)
     10. 1976: Scientific Consensus Planet Cooling, Famines imminent
     11. 1980: Acid Rain Kills Life In Lakes (additional link)
     12. 1978: No End in Sight to 30-Year Cooling Trend (additional link)
     13. 1988: Regional Droughts (that never happened) in 1990s
     14. 1988: Temperatures in DC Will Hit Record Highs
     15. 1988: Maldive Islands will Be Underwater by 2018 (they’re not)
     16. 1989: Rising Sea Levels will Obliterate Nations if Nothing Done by 2000
     17. 1989: New York City’s West Side Highway Underwater by 2019 (it’s not)
     18. 2000: Children Won’t Know what Snow Is
     19. 2002: Famine In 10 Years If We Don’t Give Up Eating Fish, Meat, and Dairy
     20. 2004: Britain will Be Siberia by 2024
     21. 2008: Arctic will Be Ice Free by 2018
     22. 2008: Climate Genius Al Gore Predicts Ice-Free Arctic by 2013
     23. 2009: Climate Genius Prince Charles Says we Have 96 Months to Save World
     24. 2009: UK Prime Minister Says 50 Days to ‘Save The Planet From Catastrophe’
     25. 2009: Climate Genius Al Gore Moves 2013 Prediction of Ice-Free Arctic to 2014
     26. 2013: Arctic Ice-Free by 2015 (additional link)
     27. 2014: Only 500 Days Before ‘Climate Chaos’
     28. 1968: Overpopulation Will Spread Worldwide
     29. 1970: World Will Use Up All its Natural Resources
     30. 1966: Oil Gone in Ten Years
     31. 1972: Oil Depleted in 20 Years
     32. 1977: Department of Energy Says Oil will Peak in 1990s
     33. 1980: Peak Oil In 2000
     34. 1996: Peak Oil in 2020
     35. 2002: Peak Oil in 2010
     36. 2006: Super Hurricanes!
     37. 2005 : Manhattan Underwater by 2015
     38. 1970: Urban Citizens Will Require Gas Masks by 1985
     39. 1970: Nitrogen buildup Will Make All Land Unusable
     40. 1970: Decaying Pollution Will Kill all the Fish
     41. 1970s: Killer Bees!

     Update: I’ve added 9 additional failed predictions (via Real Climate Science) below to make it an even 50 for the number of failed eco-pocalyptic doomsday predictions over the last 50 years.

     42. 1975: The Cooling World and a Drastic Decline in Food Production
     43. 1969: Worldwide Plague, Overwhelming Pollution, Ecological Catastrophe, Virtual Collapse of UK by End of 20th Century
     44. 1972: Pending Depletion and Shortages of Gold, Tin, Oil, Natural Gas, Copper, Aluminum
     45. 1970: Oceans Dead in a Decade, US Water Rationing by 1974, Food Rationing by 1980
     46. 1988: World’s Leading Climate Expert Predicts Lower Manhattan Underwater by 2018
     47. 2005: Fifty Million Climate Refugees by the Year 2020
     48. 2000: Snowfalls Are Now a Thing of the Past
     49.1989: UN Warns That Entire Nations Wiped Off the Face of the Earth by 2000 From Global Warming
     50. 2011: Washington Post Predicted Cherry Blossoms Blooming in Winter

https://www.aei.org/carpe-diem/50-years-of-failed-doomsday-e...
     14. 1988: Temperatures in DC Will Hit Record Highs
This prediction is now true.

Normal distribution has entered the chat

21. 2008: Arctic will Be Ice Free by 2018 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arctic_sea_ice_decline

What is your point?

The long term predictions can be correct with some error bars on the time it takes. If those bars are just a few lifetimes, sure maybe you wont see it, but that is still instant on a planetary timescale.

Some of them were just plain wrong like Elrich's prediction being unable to feed a several billion leading to mass starvation in the 70s, or the the population bomb predictions.

Basically there is ZERO accountability to making batshit insane predictions. So one is much better off as an alarmist than as a skeptic -- alarmism draws attention/funding.

But we did get an interesting movie out of the fake population bomb hysteria: Soylent Green.

     2. 1969: Everyone Will Disappear In a Cloud Of Blue Steam By 1989 (1969)
lol what is blue steam? I can't find anything about this.

Fascinating, so we're all fine? Business as usual, just what I wanted to hear.

I knew it deep down, it was all just college kids freaking out like in the 70's.

Silent spring and all that crap. Ha.

  1.  1982 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
  2.  1983 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
  3.  1984 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
  4.  1985 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
  5.  1986 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
  6.  1987 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
  7.  1988 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
  8.  1989 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
  9.  1990 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 10.  1991 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 11.  1992 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 12.  1993 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 13.  1994 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 14.  1995 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 15.  1996 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 16.  1997 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 17.  1998 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 18.  1999 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 19.  2000 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 20.  2001 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 21.  2002 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 22.  2003 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 23.  2004 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 24.  2005 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 25.  2006 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 26.  2007 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 27.  2008 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 28.  2009 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 29.  2010 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 30.  2011 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 31.  2012 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 32.  2013 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 33.  2014 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 34.  2015 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 35.  2016 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 36.  2017 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 37.  2018 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 38.  2019 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 39.  2020 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s
 40.  2021 Burning fossil fuels leads to climate desaster in 2030s

Ok? So our only problem is climate disaster and it’s not gonna happen?

I’m genuinely trying to understand your point but you seems to copy paste lists a lot.

Can you expand on what they mean for you?

2030: bonjour

I'll save this and add to list for HN post in 2040.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.