Skip to content

Comment on Google is Creating an Amazon Prime Competitor

Comments

If there's one thing Amazon could use improvement on, is it's search results. Specifically, sorting them.

Seriously, I just tried it now. My complaints:

- Why do I have to pick a department to sort? (I can kind of understand this, but it's annoying)

- Why isn't shipping taken into account when I sort?

- Why are used and new prices mixed when sorting?

While I understand that Amazon can't read my mind, there are certain product categories (cell phone cases, for example) where it's like panning for gold. You need to spend a non-trivial amount of time digging for a quality case for a good price.

I don't have a solution, but it certainly feels harder than it needs to be. Searching on newegg.com feels so much better, but I suppose they have the advantage of having a very narrow focus.

Also, sorting by reviews is broken (in the sense of being useful). A product with a single rating of 5 stars should not be ranked above a product with 1000 five-star ratings and 1 four-star rating. It's a really easy problem to solve too...

The silly thing is that IMDB figured out ranking in 1997 by using a beysian posterior mean: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_Movie_Database#Ranking...

(guess who has owned IMDB for over 10 years?)

Agree completely re: Newegg, and yet their lack of Prime and CA sales tax mean I never ever ever shop there anymore. The tax thing makes it a really unfair playing field and should be fixed.

ShopRunner (http://www.shoprunner.com/). It's basically Prime for Newegg and a bunch of other stores.

Unfortunately the tax problem still stands.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.