Skip to content

Comment on Fornjot – The world needs another CAD program

Comments

please, code first cad is not the way to go ! Did you ever use a CAD software for a proper project ? The hard stuff is in the UX/UI… or just put a DSL over CGAL and dall ir a day.

I love Rust, I love code first approach, I like this project, but the average guy trying to put a threaded hole onto an extruded profile will hardly code it…

There are no good libraries to build open source CAD on top of really. CGAL doesn't support fillets or chamfers, and you'd really want a geometric constraint solver. I think building code first is a good first step.

Code-first CAD is the way to go for some users and some use cases. I personally won't make any stronger claim than that, nor will I accept any sweeping claims to the opposite.

The average guy can keep doing what they're doing. Fornjot will not take GUI-based CAD away from them.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.