Skip to content

Comment on A complete MIDI-based framework for automatic backing tracks generation

Comments

This looks very much inspired by Band-in-a-Box.

A commercial software to generate backing music that my teacher recommended for training jazz improvisation.

The performance was okay. I found it too sterile. It didn’t really swing … especially for the target audience of jazz musicians. It was helpful though!

Judging from its look and feel, Band-in-a-Box is around since the 90s.

This uses accompaniment styles from Yamaha arranger keyboards, which have been around for ages. It's a much simpler format (really just a special kind of MIDI file) than the BIAB one, and more open. This project has details: https://github.com/bures/sff2-tools . There's a site that's popular with users of Yamaha keyboards, www.jososoft.dk , that has tons of styles in various genres.

I messed around with JJazzLab a few months ago, and, while I did encounter some annoying MIDI problems involving the drum patches, I liked it enough that I wrote myself a script to import a song from another program, Impro-Visor, for auditioning in JJazzLab. It's a lot easier to use than Band in a Box.

Since they allow you to import Band-in-a-Box files, I'd say they're well aware of the prior art.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.