Skip to content

Comment on Bunny DNS – A scriptable DNS platform

Comments

Can't make an account with a .me tld in my email...

I assume it's a Protonmail account, I noticed many websites say a "pm.me" email address is invalid.

At my employer, some users register with a pm.me email address. When users contact us via email, they use a different protonmail address and never the pm.me address. I know you can never rely on the sender address, but from a support perspective this is still strange and extremely troublesome (for example it is tedious to assign the user to an account). I assume that Protonmail users can only receive emails with pm.me, but not send them. For me actually a reason to block pm.me or to handle it like a throwaway address.

In ProtonMail you can have email aliases (different address for the same inbox). By default, user@protonmail.com and user@pm.me exist. You can both send and receive from them.

to block pm.me or to handle it like a throwaway address

How is a pm.me address more throwaway than a GMail one? I would say it's the other way around, especially considering that many ProtonMail users pay for their email service, so it's more likely to be a real user behind the address.

You can both send and receive from them.

This is not quite correct. According to Protonmail:

but sending emails from a @pm.me email address requires a paid account.

https://protonmail.com/support/knowledge-base/pm-me-addresse...

My criticism is: You should never use an e-mail address from which you cannot send. This has nothing to do with Protonmail but is a problem in general.

but sending emails from a @pm.me email address requires a paid account.

Forgot that, I personally have a paid account and I think many people using Protonmail do, the free accounts are not so good.

You should never use an e-mail address from which you cannot send.

Depends for what, if you subscribe to newsletters you don't have to send emails, but I agree it's pretty dangerous to use an email that you don't have send access for.

Fine for me with .me email.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.