Skip to content

Comment on Software engineering ethics by Uncle Bobparent

Comments

I'm as usual Out Of the Loop. Why we're considering him a renegade now?

A lot of people seem to consider him an out of touch architect astronaut peddling snake oil that doesn't have any relevance to actually writing real software in the real world.

Personally I think he has more misses than hits and everything he writes should be taken with a large grain of salt, but occasionally he hits upon some interesting ideas.

I've been closely following him eversince he first got into the spotlight. He got famous in the tech community because he's been preaching about tdd and later on clean code before it got widely accepted to be good practice. Because of this the tech community treated him like a divine preacher and it seems like this got to him and went into his head. His persona "Uncle Bob" is this wise and all knowing guy who has ideas way ahead of everybody else but like most people he had more misses then hits. It seems like he's chasing "controversially big ideas" which he presents like they're truths and this can be pretty tiring to read.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.