Skip to content

Comment on What would it take to recreate dplyr in Python? (2020)parent

Comments

Apart from grouping, custom indexes are great as default columns for joins.

I just wish Pandas treated named index columns as columns. When I write df["blah"], I don't want to have to remember whether I just loaded the data and it's a normal column or if I just grouped on "blah" and it's an index column.

Currently, in the latter case, subscripting doesn't work and you either have to do a reset_index() or look up the correct incantation -- something like df.index.get_level("blah").

I have a feeling that the root of the problem is that Pandas ended up the same concept of "index" both for optimized lookup and for the UI of grouping / joining. My guess is that get_level is less efficient than it should be, and thus Pandas discourages using it by making it obscure.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.