Skip to content

Comment on Will the Chinese Civil War End with a Bang or with a Whimper?parent

Comments

Uh Hong Kong wasn't invaded? The British returned control of it to China when the '100 year lease' expired. Somewhat similar situation with a foreign power supporting a democratic government, except support for Taiwan is much more popular domestically in the US.

I didn’t say that Hong Kong was invaded. It is Taiwan that would require an invasion. Hence there isn’t really any comparing Hong Kong to Taiwan. So thanks for making my point.

Taiwan that would require an invasion

Maybe at this date & time, but I'd bet in the next 100 years there will be a non military unification. To me it seems like there hasn't been much of a fundamental change in Geo-Politics around Taiwan in a long time... and that the main reason an invasion of Taiwan is being brought up in US media is ironically because of how poorly NeoLiberalism FP went in Afghanistan.

Actually only New Territories were later leased, the main part of Kowlung and Hong Kong Island were ceded to the British in perpetuity under the Convention of Peking.

The British ceded the main parts of Hong Kong back along with the return of New Territories under the understanding that there would be one country and two systems.

In the 70s and 80s the British government did everything Beijing asked with things like not making Hong Kongers full British citizens.

Those compromises were supposed to gain something for the people of Hong Kong after reunification with PRC.

It’s Xi that’s renegaded on that promise and refused to allow a free press or opposition politicians to stand in Hong Kong.

You’d be mad to think that this time “peaceful” unification would be anything more than “do what we say, say what we say and we won’t shoot you family”.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.