Comment on Ask HN: Blockchain success stories that did need to be decentralised?parentComments−nradov4yThe owner of NYSE isn't a market maker. ICE provides exchange and clearing services. Some of their largest customers are market makers.There is no evidence that a Blockchain based approach would provide more transparency or stability. In fact the opposite is likely true.−danielmarkbruce4yThese kinds of errors - claiming an exchange is a market maker for example - seem to be minor errors. But every single argument in favor of a blockchain seems to have one or two of them which make the argument flawed.
Comments
The owner of NYSE isn't a market maker. ICE provides exchange and clearing services. Some of their largest customers are market makers.
There is no evidence that a Blockchain based approach would provide more transparency or stability. In fact the opposite is likely true.
These kinds of errors - claiming an exchange is a market maker for example - seem to be minor errors. But every single argument in favor of a blockchain seems to have one or two of them which make the argument flawed.