Skip to content

Comment on Female thriller writer who won €1m literary prize revealed to be three menparent

Comments

It's not about using a pen name. They are free to write under a feminine pseudonym (reverse George Elliot style).

I am not sure if the prize is intentionally limited to women --it sounds like it isn't--but I dont think we want people claiming prizes this way. Consider that there are competitions for eg. high school students, first time authors, etc.

The first rule of high school student contest will be that you need to be in high school. For feminists, they have shot themselves in foot in this regard. They want that everyone to be treated equal(and in many case not even define females) but at the same time they don't.

If the prize is not restricted to female authors, what's the problem?

Your argument would hold if the article actually mentioned anything like that, but all that's being discussed is if it was a marketing strategy or not.

This is peak hypocrisy when we're supposed to believe that women are constantly held back, but accuse men of using a woman pen name to sell more.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.