These are all good reasons to bring back vote counts (which, again, I'm in favor of) but only your point (2) is a reply to my question about this particular case. (1) and (3) would apply to any comment here on HN.
I guess what I didn't take into account in my previous comment is that the guy responsible for the animated GIF might drop by HN and might take the GGP's comment more seriously if he sees a large number of votes attached to it. This makes sense and is another good reason to get vote counts back here, especially if it discourages others from posting me-too comments.
Comments
These are all good reasons to bring back vote counts (which, again, I'm in favor of) but only your point (2) is a reply to my question about this particular case. (1) and (3) would apply to any comment here on HN.
I guess what I didn't take into account in my previous comment is that the guy responsible for the animated GIF might drop by HN and might take the GGP's comment more seriously if he sees a large number of votes attached to it. This makes sense and is another good reason to get vote counts back here, especially if it discourages others from posting me-too comments.