Therefore you can take any 10 good logos or designs, or even well composed photos, and you'll probably find in 7 out of them the golden ratio implemented somehow!
The issue, though, is defining «has the golden ratio implemented somehow» in a way that it wouldn't be more likely than not that the golden ratio would be considered «implemented» more often than not if the hypothesis were false anyways.
Comments
http://www.macrumors.com/2011/06/16/icloud-logo-infused-with...
BS is called in the comments section of this article
Here's the comment by cheesymogul: http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?p=12774665#post12...
Therefore you can take any 10 good logos or designs, or even well composed photos, and you'll probably find in 7 out of them the golden ratio implemented somehow!
Sounds like a testable claim to me.
The issue, though, is defining «has the golden ratio implemented somehow» in a way that it wouldn't be more likely than not that the golden ratio would be considered «implemented» more often than not if the hypothesis were false anyways.