Skip to content

Comment on Silent Running: The sci-fi that predicted modern crisesparent

Comments

I actually appreciate your point and those of all similar commenters. I think what bothered me is that a criticism as diffuse as “the system“ is without value because it means everything and nothing.

It also seems not to acknowledge that “the system“ has produced enormous medical and economic advances right along with the many destructive forces it has unleashed. For example, poverty is massively reduced since I was a kid. That is almost completely due to free market forces applied by “the system“.

Please understand I am not trying to defend “the system“ as a whole. I am simply trying to say that a blanket derogation of it does no one any good.

What I said is: the movie must be [one of the reasons] why I [grew up to] hate the system so much.

What I did not say: the entire system sucks.

What you claim that I said: the entire system sucks.

That's the maze of the human psyche for you.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.