Skip to content

Comment on Knolling

Comments

I disagree with this.

I want a clean, well organized workspace (or house, or room, etc.) as much as anyone but the process of tidying, or organizing, should not be mistaken for anything other than a time bank from which we make deposits and take withdrawals.

It is possible to keep a space tidy and organized at all times, but that implies constant and immediate reaction to all misplacement and disorganization.

To put it into computing terms, it is the same thing as running a CPU with no cache or a display with no buffer[1]. These things are possible, but they require immediate responses and prioritizing efforts becomes impossible. You simply must deal with these instructions right now.

That's possible in human terms, with physical workspaces, but it drives people crazy and is practically impossible. If you view clutter and disorganization as a time bank, or time buffer, you can make judicious deposits and withdrawals that suit you and your environment.

[1] Yes, you can run a display with no framebuffer - it is called "racing the beam" and is described in a wonderful book about the Atari VCS titled _Racing the Beam_.

any1OP

The article is about the importance of keeping your code clean. Do you disagree that it's important to keep your code clean?

I'm sorry, I don't see how your analogy with computer architecture applies. Like with all things, knolling can be taken to an extreme, but as I understand it, the idea is to keep shared work stations clean and ready for the next person or yourself and to keep things organised while you're working, in such a way that you don't have to go looking for tools that you need.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.