Skip to content

Comment on An Unprecedented Attack on Press Freedomparent

Comments

"The framers weren't stupid lol" isn't a compelling argument.

Show me documentary evidence or legal precedent from the time demonstrating that intent on the part of the framers, or else you're just projecting.

After all, apparently everyone was wrong about what "well regulated militia" actually meant until 2008. So it must not all be as crystal clear and elementary as you claim.

Muddying the water has been a successful strategy for lawyers for millennia. That does not make it less reprehensible to do, nor justify being fooled by it.

There were a lot of lawyers among the framers. They didn't choose the wording of something as important as the First Amendment randomly.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.