The point of a stand up is to get everyone face to face to enable quick interactions and collaboration, and to do so in a very lightweight way.
Doing it as you suggest is simply doing daily update reports and negates the point of a daily scrum.
I feel often Agile principles are taken as buzzwords without really trying to understand the point. Now, whether the point works for you and your team is another question.
Comments
The point of a stand up is to get everyone face to face to enable quick interactions and collaboration, and to do so in a very lightweight way.
Doing it as you suggest is simply doing daily update reports and negates the point of a daily scrum.
I feel often Agile principles are taken as buzzwords without really trying to understand the point. Now, whether the point works for you and your team is another question.