Skip to content

Comment on "What society overwhelmingly asks for is snake oil" (1994)parent

Comments

Do you believe everything must be explicitly defensible within the irrational and innately egotistical and greedy philosophies of finance?

FWIW, finance bigwigs live in actual luxuirous ivory towers.

finance doesn't magically confer certain properties on humans. human seek to satisfy their wants with limited means. does the pursuit of money lead to evils? sure, but money is only a stand in for other wants. money is a good because it is transparent in a way that other methods of accounting for the distribution of goods isn't. if you can quantify the resources that go towards X instead of Y and yet society claims to value Y above X you have some very useful data to investigate. contrast this with the primary competition for money as a means of distribution: opaque and non-fungible social favor. when a system of social favor redirects resources in a way inconsistent with values it isn't a simple matter of pointing to quantifiable numbers.

No, I believe that if an academic can't convince a layperson that what he or she does it worthwhile, they have no business asking them to work harder for longer for less to pay for it.

When did you last see a professor working for free?

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.