I asked for an objective definition of what over-commenting would be.
I don't think what you're asking for is possible. It's an inherently subjective standard.
If an objective definition were possible, then it'd be possible to write a static analysis tool that reads both your code and the comments and flags "over-commenting on line 23, under-commenting on line 457". That could be done with sufficiently advanced AI, but at that point it would just be the subjective opinion of the tool's author being enforced.
Comments
I don't think what you're asking for is possible. It's an inherently subjective standard.
If an objective definition were possible, then it'd be possible to write a static analysis tool that reads both your code and the comments and flags "over-commenting on line 23, under-commenting on line 457". That could be done with sufficiently advanced AI, but at that point it would just be the subjective opinion of the tool's author being enforced.