Skip to content

Comment on Cellebrite claims it can unlock any iPhone, many new Android phones for policeparent

Comments

Apple can't patch it. It's a fundamental limitation that, somewhere on the device, is stored a key; if you can extract that key, then you can run brute-force on it as much as you want from a supercomputer. And it has to be extractable because the phone itself has to use it.

The Secure Enclave prevents this

It's supposed to. We don't even know for sure that there's a flaw in it; they might have just bypassed it, found a way to read the flash memory directly.

The memory used by the SEP is encrypted.

With a key. Which is stored in SEP hardware. Which could, in theory, be extracted.

I'm not saying extraction is technically impossible, just that you can't simply bypass the SEP and read its flash the way hardware reversers do with other embedded systems.

The secure enclave SHOULD prevent this! The cellebrite people found some vulnerability, but we dont know in which component.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.