Comment on 737: The Max MessparentComments−kevin_thibedeau7yEgypt air pilots performed the recovery procedure and still crashed. Pretty damning evidence that it can't fly safely with MCAS off.−cmurf7yPost hoc ergo propter hoc is a logical fallacy. Very basic.MCAS caused the extreme mistrim that resulted in the crash. Turning it off does not solve the mistrim.−kevin_thibedeau7yThe procedure includes manually correcting the trim. It didn't work.
Comments
Egypt air pilots performed the recovery procedure and still crashed. Pretty damning evidence that it can't fly safely with MCAS off.
Post hoc ergo propter hoc is a logical fallacy. Very basic.
MCAS caused the extreme mistrim that resulted in the crash. Turning it off does not solve the mistrim.
The procedure includes manually correcting the trim. It didn't work.