Comment on Yacc is deadComments−amichail15yWhy was it rejected by ESOP?−stupidsignup15yWell, if you want to know what ESOP rejection reviews look like: http://phlegmaticprogrammer.wordpress.com/2010/11/21/reviews...and the response to these reviews here: http://phlegmaticprogrammer.wordpress.com/2010/11/21/respons...−fizx15yPossibly because they hand-waved away a lot of formal specification of their solution. For example, there was no attempt to analyze the complexity of the generated rules trees.
Comments
Why was it rejected by ESOP?
Well, if you want to know what ESOP rejection reviews look like: http://phlegmaticprogrammer.wordpress.com/2010/11/21/reviews...
and the response to these reviews here: http://phlegmaticprogrammer.wordpress.com/2010/11/21/respons...
Possibly because they hand-waved away a lot of formal specification of their solution. For example, there was no attempt to analyze the complexity of the generated rules trees.