Agreed. I think downvoting starts a revenge cycle, and the methods that are in place to prevent revenge only make the revenge less direct.
For instance, you can't downvote replies to your comment, but you can go into their user history and downvote their other comments. This is worse, because their other comments quite literally have nothing to do with what would have been downvoted had that measure not been in place.
If someone views downvotes as punishment, then this engenders retaliation, and retaliation doesn't engender civil discussion.
Comments
Agreed. I think downvoting starts a revenge cycle, and the methods that are in place to prevent revenge only make the revenge less direct.
For instance, you can't downvote replies to your comment, but you can go into their user history and downvote their other comments. This is worse, because their other comments quite literally have nothing to do with what would have been downvoted had that measure not been in place.
If someone views downvotes as punishment, then this engenders retaliation, and retaliation doesn't engender civil discussion.
Actually downvoting a bunch of someone's comments doesn't work. There has long been protection against that.
You can't down vote old comments, so there history is safe.