Skip to content

Comment on Supreme Court Should Say No to Patents That Take Old Ideas Away from the Public

Comments

So this new version of patent trolling is to find old valuable patents that can be invalidated in some way, and patent them again, then sue everyone in the world that "infringes" because they thought the patent was long expired? Wow, that is a new level of scumbaggery.

That’s not at all what Ariosa stands for.

Not new. Turbotax has long lobbied the government to make the tax law convoluted so you have to use Turbotax (or another similarsoftware) so you can avoid fines for submitting the wrong amount of taxes.

I don't feel like thats quite the same thing but I also hate it.

That has nothing to do with patents and/or patent trolling. You don't need to pay patent royalties to file your taxes.. (for example)

You're correct that it doesn't have to do with patents. But the point is about abusing the legal system to extract value from others. What Turbotax does is worse. So it is not a "new level" of abuse of the legal system.

Both are arguably forms of rent-seeking.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.