This is another one of those stories that ought to be shocking but is unlikely to move the dial.
No. This is an outrage and the British people will rightly be outraged. The effects of this will and should be felt in the next election and beyond. Your sophisticated world-weary cynicism is counterproductive.
I'd like to be wrong, but I suspect that outside of people who are already in the labour movement, nobody will be talking about this next week let alone the next election. How much of a role did SDS play at the last election, when that was already known about?
It's been ""known"" for years that Special Branch helped murder people in Northern Ireland, and outside the republican community and the small subset of mainland "left" that pays attention, it makes no difference.
(Far too many of the "british people" read rightwing press outlets which will minimise this and some other issue, probably Brexit, to rile up their readers to demand more not less authoritarianism)
The same police were doing the same things when Labour was in government. Also, Labour this time around want more money for the police, and we wouldn't really call Labour anti authoritarian, would we?
"The government always wins the election" is a very typical British saying and quite true.
How will they be felt in the election, given the subject? The political group it was on behalf of has repaid the police by slashing police budgets and reducing their numbers, so we are currently in the position where the left wing are the party claiming to represent the police and are promising a rapid increase in police numbers, so they are unlikely to want to rock the boat too much against them politically at the moment, as that would muddy the messaging they are trying to get out.
Briton here. The vast majority of people will not care at all.
I object to the term 'cynicism'. Inductive reasoning, maybe. There's nothing inherent in the definition of a British person that necessarily includes apathy towards current affairs.
But most swans are white, there's nothing cynical about that, and similarly I say with no cynicism that most British people forgot about this five minutes after hearing/reading about it, if they heard or read about it at all.
Yeah, I'm not really sure about that. I'm pretty politically engaged and I barely give a shit about this, considering the current clusterfuck that is politics in Britain.
Switzerland is resolutely boring and mostly has problems relating to "where do we keep all this foreign money". Germany seems to be doing well at the moment; I'd also list the Netherlands and the scandiavian countries as generally more sensible.
The option of "bonkers, but in a completely different way" politics is available in France, Belgium and Italy. You can also have "corrupt but extremely safe for the general public" in Singapore and Japan.
Should, perhaps, but as a Brit my reaction was just a complete lack of surprise. I'd be shocked if most people even remember this in a few month's time, if they care at all. I also can't see it billowing out in the election - the misdeeds of the police aren't necessarily translated onto the government, and a lot of people will have bigger things to worry about come election time.
Comments
No. This is an outrage and the British people will rightly be outraged. The effects of this will and should be felt in the next election and beyond. Your sophisticated world-weary cynicism is counterproductive.
I'd like to be wrong, but I suspect that outside of people who are already in the labour movement, nobody will be talking about this next week let alone the next election. How much of a role did SDS play at the last election, when that was already known about?
It's been ""known"" for years that Special Branch helped murder people in Northern Ireland, and outside the republican community and the small subset of mainland "left" that pays attention, it makes no difference.
https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/opinion/news-analysis/how...
(Far too many of the "british people" read rightwing press outlets which will minimise this and some other issue, probably Brexit, to rile up their readers to demand more not less authoritarianism)
The same police were doing the same things when Labour was in government. Also, Labour this time around want more money for the police, and we wouldn't really call Labour anti authoritarian, would we?
"The government always wins the election" is a very typical British saying and quite true.
I don't know what fantasy land you live in but it isn't the UK.
Almost nobody will give a shit.
Those that do won't remember come election time.
How will they be felt in the election, given the subject? The political group it was on behalf of has repaid the police by slashing police budgets and reducing their numbers, so we are currently in the position where the left wing are the party claiming to represent the police and are promising a rapid increase in police numbers, so they are unlikely to want to rock the boat too much against them politically at the moment, as that would muddy the messaging they are trying to get out.
Briton here. The vast majority of people will not care at all.
I object to the term 'cynicism'. Inductive reasoning, maybe. There's nothing inherent in the definition of a British person that necessarily includes apathy towards current affairs.
But most swans are white, there's nothing cynical about that, and similarly I say with no cynicism that most British people forgot about this five minutes after hearing/reading about it, if they heard or read about it at all.
The British people rarely express outrage at this kind of thing.
Yeah, I'm not really sure about that. I'm pretty politically engaged and I barely give a shit about this, considering the current clusterfuck that is politics in Britain.
Are there any countries in the world where politics is not like this?
Any?
Switzerland is resolutely boring and mostly has problems relating to "where do we keep all this foreign money". Germany seems to be doing well at the moment; I'd also list the Netherlands and the scandiavian countries as generally more sensible.
The option of "bonkers, but in a completely different way" politics is available in France, Belgium and Italy. You can also have "corrupt but extremely safe for the general public" in Singapore and Japan.
Should, perhaps, but as a Brit my reaction was just a complete lack of surprise. I'd be shocked if most people even remember this in a few month's time, if they care at all. I also can't see it billowing out in the election - the misdeeds of the police aren't necessarily translated onto the government, and a lot of people will have bigger things to worry about come election time.
Should? Yes. Will? No.
Painfully naive idealism isn't any different. You have to work with reality, not deny it.
This won't happen. If you're a wagering man, i'll happily take the other side of a bet about it.
You obviously don't know the British.
This is a product of monarchy, and going to your parliment won't fix it.
Monarchy no, privilege yes. And of course the rightwing press.