Comment on Ask News.YC: Proposed experiment to test "The PG bias"Comments−dangoldin18yAn idea I just thought of would be to keep the poster anonymous until the post achieves a certain rating - after that show who the poster is.If there actually is favoritism this might solve that issue somewhat and yet give people credit where it's due.−llimllib18yyes, but sometimes the reputation is valuable. Given a poster's prior probability of intelligent comments, you have more information on which to vote.−attack18yYou also allow him to relax his quality while enjoying his automatic points. Plus group-think lock-in for free.I can only reducing this making the overall quality here improve.
Comments
An idea I just thought of would be to keep the poster anonymous until the post achieves a certain rating - after that show who the poster is.
If there actually is favoritism this might solve that issue somewhat and yet give people credit where it's due.
yes, but sometimes the reputation is valuable. Given a poster's prior probability of intelligent comments, you have more information on which to vote.
You also allow him to relax his quality while enjoying his automatic points. Plus group-think lock-in for free.
I can only reducing this making the overall quality here improve.