Skip to content

Comment on The Worsening Cosmic Ray Situationparent

Comments

That won't help. The closest GRB we've detected was about 100M light years away, so well outside the galaxy. If we had one happen within our galaxy that's beamed towards us, I don't think that 10ly make any practical difference in the 1/r^2 attenuated flux. Also, the beams are thought to be several degrees wide, so unless it's a very close GRB (in which case we should consider other problems), it's also unlikely that 10ly would move is out of the beam.

Source: former astrophysicist. Also if I remember correctly, the Wikipedia article on grbs is actually decent. (Edit: overstated things - need coffee, I suppose)

How does one relinquish one's credentials as an astrophysicist? If you have the education and can do the math, is it not a title you bear for life?

I always thought of it as a profession, not a title.

I do have a degree, though, so it's purely a matter of perspective.

I would guess and say "changed field", so Astrophysics is no longer primary.

Still an astrophysicist. I'm a Computer Scientist. I won't cease being one even if I change professions, I will just be whatever I become in addition to a CS.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.