I'm inferring what you said from replies, but I think your concern can be applied to pretty much all medical care.
If we vaccinate -> mutants with natural resistance have to compete with the susceptible.
Antibiotics -> People with strong immune systems and good hygiene have to compete with dirty weaklings.
Treatment of heart disease -> people with bad habits and bad genetics live longer, gather more resources for their descendants.
And on and on.
(Of course I'm being a little sarcastic above but I certainly don't mean to mock those that benefit greatly from medical intervention, I'm one of them)
I think this situation is a little different and more complex than the examples you're comparing. I've worked in a NICU, and I've seen that many of the babies in it stay for several months at a time. Keeping these babies alive can be extremely expensive, and while considering costs in these situations is ugly, it is something that we have to do. Along with the costs, we have to consider the outcomes for these babies. We've only been able to keep babies born at ~20 weeks alive for a short time in medical history - we don't have a great idea about the long term outcome for them. We know that many of these babies are still alive, but we also know that many of them die very young from complications of pre-maturity like underdeveloped lungs, brain hemorrhage, necrosis of the GI tract, congenital heart defects, and sepsis.
The right thing to do isn't clear cut in this situation. Going to great lengths to save or prolong every baby's life isn't clearly a good thing, but neither is refusing care for premature babies.
True, but I think this is actually what an MRI can help with. If you can see soon after birth that a baby has suffered serious brain damage, you can avoid getting the parents' hopes up, just to have them crushed later.
You guessed right.i had a similar comment when they wanted all diseases out of the world.. Nobody will have a natural immune system and 1 variant could show up and it could go really fast then. :)
Comments
I'm inferring what you said from replies, but I think your concern can be applied to pretty much all medical care.
If we vaccinate -> mutants with natural resistance have to compete with the susceptible.
Antibiotics -> People with strong immune systems and good hygiene have to compete with dirty weaklings.
Treatment of heart disease -> people with bad habits and bad genetics live longer, gather more resources for their descendants.
And on and on.
(Of course I'm being a little sarcastic above but I certainly don't mean to mock those that benefit greatly from medical intervention, I'm one of them)
I think this situation is a little different and more complex than the examples you're comparing. I've worked in a NICU, and I've seen that many of the babies in it stay for several months at a time. Keeping these babies alive can be extremely expensive, and while considering costs in these situations is ugly, it is something that we have to do. Along with the costs, we have to consider the outcomes for these babies. We've only been able to keep babies born at ~20 weeks alive for a short time in medical history - we don't have a great idea about the long term outcome for them. We know that many of these babies are still alive, but we also know that many of them die very young from complications of pre-maturity like underdeveloped lungs, brain hemorrhage, necrosis of the GI tract, congenital heart defects, and sepsis.
The right thing to do isn't clear cut in this situation. Going to great lengths to save or prolong every baby's life isn't clearly a good thing, but neither is refusing care for premature babies.
True, but I think this is actually what an MRI can help with. If you can see soon after birth that a baby has suffered serious brain damage, you can avoid getting the parents' hopes up, just to have them crushed later.
You guessed right.i had a similar comment when they wanted all diseases out of the world.. Nobody will have a natural immune system and 1 variant could show up and it could go really fast then. :)
Eyeglasses -> Us nearsighted spread our dirty genes.