Skip to content

Comment on Browser History (2013)

Comments

It's hard to take this seriously because the page itself does not work correctly w.r.t. the back button.

For example, if I click through to the http 1.1 spec in the first paragraph, then hit "Back" I see the scrollbar shrink as new content is loaded and uBlock's block count increases as new content loads.

If I scroll to the bottom of the page, click a link, and then click back, I don't even go back to the same spot - I'm at the end of the article and content loads below it...

My expectation as a user, regardless of the spec, is that I should see exactly what I saw when I was just on the page. Render to a bitmap, and when I click "back" display the bitmap. If going back to the page requires any network requests then the page is doing it wrong.

The exception that proves the rule would be streaming content.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.