Skip to content

Comment on And so it begins... Seton Hill University to give all students an iPadparent

Comments

If the file sharing is similar to the iPhone (and it looks that way) it's going to be a lousy share-by-email experience.

That's funny, because I never mail myself documents on the iPhone.

You can't use the Dropbox app (or similar), because Dropbox files live in the "Dropbox" directory

If all you want is to read a document, what's the problem?

And note-taking? Sure you're joking. The iPad is a "hunt-and-peck-required" device.

And you're basing this on what data?

I suspect this will end up as a major disappointment -- the iPad isn't ready to replace a laptop yet. It's a consumer's device, and college isn't exclusively about consumption of content.

Currently, everyone needs a laptop to sync content with an iPad. If everyone has a laptop, what's the problem? It's not as if college is devoid of consuming content.

Also, everything you point out looks like a business opportunity to me, not some sort of overwhelming world-halting problem.

> And you're basing this on what data?

Steve Jobs fumbling his way through a single sentence during the original iPad launch, and the hunt-and-peck typing used in the promotional videos.

> It's not as if college is devoid of consuming content.

Agreed, but if you need a real laptop anyway (Mathematica, writing essays, etc, etc), is it really worth it to carry both?

If your're set to do some heavy reading, does it pay to lug your laptop? Maybe if you want to do some browsing or tinkering. The iPad can do the former now. The latter will get implemented for lots of uses, for profit.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.