Indeed, I know what you've written and I agree with it -- writing it all in the first place would've resulted in a wall of text! I'm still unsure if there's a real benefit in this technology, or if the same result can be obtained by increasing the bit precison in the ADC stage of a "normal" sensor.
Even if there were, I pointed at the Foveon X3 as an example of a very good technology that was regardarded as a breakthrough but didn't really make it commercially. Another "revolutionary" idea that was marketed as something that "would change the way we take photographs" were the Lytro cameras, with their unique focus technology, that works by taking the picture in a different way than a classic camera, wich allows to change the focus of the picture working with the "raw" file. Even though that technology is also very interesting, it has remained in a niche market and only offered by one company -- more novelty than "mainstream" photography.
Yes, it's a shame Foveon wasn't a commercial success, the quality in some areas is close to medium format. You can pick dp Merrill's up on ebay for about $300, would be tempted if it could do half decent video too.
I don't think Lytro will ever take off in the way they intended, but light field capture will be very hot for 3D360 VR in a couple of years, when we start seeing first light field goggles (like Magic Leap)
Comments
Indeed, I know what you've written and I agree with it -- writing it all in the first place would've resulted in a wall of text! I'm still unsure if there's a real benefit in this technology, or if the same result can be obtained by increasing the bit precison in the ADC stage of a "normal" sensor.
Even if there were, I pointed at the Foveon X3 as an example of a very good technology that was regardarded as a breakthrough but didn't really make it commercially. Another "revolutionary" idea that was marketed as something that "would change the way we take photographs" were the Lytro cameras, with their unique focus technology, that works by taking the picture in a different way than a classic camera, wich allows to change the focus of the picture working with the "raw" file. Even though that technology is also very interesting, it has remained in a niche market and only offered by one company -- more novelty than "mainstream" photography.
Yes, it's a shame Foveon wasn't a commercial success, the quality in some areas is close to medium format. You can pick dp Merrill's up on ebay for about $300, would be tempted if it could do half decent video too.
I don't think Lytro will ever take off in the way they intended, but light field capture will be very hot for 3D360 VR in a couple of years, when we start seeing first light field goggles (like Magic Leap)