Skip to content

Ask HN: Are current on-device LLMs useless?

1 pointjdthedisciple1 comment
On HN

I found this model "lfm2.5-thinking" which is "designed for on-device deployment" and is really tiny: just 1.2b params (~700 MB)

My first and very short interaction was so terrible that I felt no need to continue, but not in the way you think:

Here is the extremely brief transcript:

    >>> hey
    Thinking...
    Okay, let's see what the user wrote here. They just said "heat". Hmm, maybe they want a response to that? ... First "heat" could be a standalone message...
You saw that? It misread my "hey" as "heat", and kept going like this throughout the entire thinking process.

I thought I know what to expect from tiny local models like this.

But I did not expect it to be this bad. How would this be useful for anything local if it cannot even read a three letter-word properly?

Is this just lfm2.5 being terrible, or is this level of error a common trait in this model size range. Curious to hear from other folks' experiences.

Comments

The new Siri is on-device and people are reporting pretty good results. It's much larger than 1.2B though.

AboutSource Built by g1lg1l

Hackerly is an independent reader for Hacker News, built on the public HN API. Not affiliated with Y Combinator.